OneAdvanced Software (return to the home page)

The real cost of getting time and pay wrong

Payroll errors usually start before the payroll run. Learn where pay goes wrong, why one person is a single point of failure and what it really costs.

by Adam Bowles Country Director - ANZ

Published on 18 November 2026 2 minute read
cost of time and pay wrong ANZ Blog

In Episode 2 of Clocked In: ANZ Workforce Trends, Head of Sales Kwame Aforo-Addo and Solutions Lead Marcus Sweeney look at where pay actually goes wrong, why one person should never be your safety net, and what an error really costs once you count more than fines.

Watch Episode 2

Key takeaways

  • Pay errors usually start before payroll, with the time and roster data payroll receives.
  • Payroll can run flawlessly and still create compliance risk if the underlying data is wrong.
  • Relying on one person to interpret award rules is a single point of failure.
  • The hidden costs (conversations, recalculations, audits, lost trust) are often bigger than the correction itself.
  • Employees trust time capture when they can see their records and query them.

Where does pay actually go wrong?

It's tempting to blame payroll. The root cause usually sits much earlier.

Take a simple scenario. Someone picks up a last-minute shift the day before payroll. The change is agreed over the phone or in a message, but the planned roster is the one that carries through. Payroll applies all its rules correctly, yet receives the wrong data. The employee then has to raise the discrepancy with their manager and work out how to fix it.

What has to work before the pay run?

A handful of things simply need to work:

  • Accurate time captured up front.
  • Approvals far enough ahead of the payroll export. It's a constant challenge when a shift finishes at 4am the night before a pay run and someone still has to approve the overtime before it's pushed through.
  • The right award interpretation applied before the data moves to payroll.

Is this only a small business problem?

No. The Fair Work Ombudsman recovered $453 million for more than 181,000 underpaid workers in 2025-26, taking back-payments to almost $2.5 billion over six years. Close to half of 2025-26 recoveries came from large corporate employers. The year before, the figure was $358 million for more than 249,000 workers, with about 60% from large corporates.

The episode makes the same point: large employers with mature payroll functions and big finance teams are still being caught. Workforce compliance challenges can affect even the most resourced organisations.

It's a trans-Tasman issue too. Estimates reported by RNZ have put the potential cost of Holidays Act pay errors in New Zealand at more than $2 billion.

What is the single point of failure risk in payroll?

If one person manually corrects data and holds the rules in their head, you have a single point of failure. All it takes is illness, a family bereavement or a resignation, and the business can't pay people correctly.

Questions worth asking today:

  • How much of the rules knowledge is documented, and how much lives in one person's memory or a spreadsheet only they can find?
  • Who owns the interpretation: a system or a person? What happens when the rules change, and who is responsible for acting on that?
  • Have you tested real scenarios? Think approved and unapproved overtime, allowances and penalties for overnight shifts, and how breaks and changes in duties affect the award calculation.

Automation helps, but only once the right rules are configured. And review them regularly. Problems often don't appear at go-live. They surface six months later, or at the turn of the financial year when rates and conditions change.

What are the hidden costs of a pay discrepancy?

They're hard to quantify, but they add up. The employee raises the issue with their manager. The manager takes it to payroll. Payroll retrieves records and recalculates, sometimes by hand. When several employees raise the same issue, across one site or many, payroll, HR, finance and sometimes external specialists get pulled in to check nothing systemic is going on. Repeat that, and people lose confidence in the process.

OneAdvanced customers have seen what removing that friction is worth:

  • CDC NSW eliminated more than 1,500 paper timesheets a week and saves an average of $120,000 a year through standardised rostering and award interpretation. [Read the case study]
  • BKH Group found an average 5% discrepancy in recorded hours, equal to hundreds of lost labour hours each month, and saves around $250,000 a year. [Read the case study]

How do you get employees to trust time capture?

It comes down to enablement and adoption. Show people how the records in the system help them understand how their time is spent and what they'll be paid. Give them visibility of their own records and a way to query discrepancies and see the result.

During implementation, bring employees in early. Show them the system, the common tasks they'll do every day and the ones they'll only do a few times a year. After go-live, keep support and documentation easy to reach so people can get unstuck.

What are the warning signs your current approach isn't working?

  • One person owns payroll, and one person knows how the rules are applied.
  • Discrepancies keep arising, and you make frequent retrospective changes.
  • Managers and payroll regularly field requests from employees asking why they weren't paid correctly.
  • You use contractors or labour hire and can't say whether you track their time, or are just paying the invoices you're sent.

The real cost goes beyond dollars. It's the loss of employee trust, and of confidence in your organisation's reputation for doing right by its people. As the episode puts it, getting time and pay right isn't the end goal. It's the starting point.

Explore how OneAdvanced Time and Attendance connects accurate time capture, built-in award interpretation and payroll, or read our guide to award interpretation in Australia.

Up next in the series: Episode 3, What Employee Empowerment and Real-Time Visibility Actually Change Day to Day. Register once to watch the whole series.

FAQs

About the author


Adam Bowles

Country Director - ANZ

Share

Contact our sales and support teams. We're here to help.

Contact Us
Speak to our sales team

Speak to our expert consultants for personalised advice and recommendations or to book a demo.

Call us on

1300 884 831