Skip to main content
OneAdvanced Software (return to the home page)

7 Discussion points to cover during performance conversations

Seven topics to cover in performance conversations and check-ins, with sample questions, a preparation checklist and a follow-up template.

by Joe Julian Product Manager - People & Workforce Management

Published on 11 February 2017 7 minute read
performance-conversations-discussion-points

Regular check-ins give managers and employees time to discuss progress, address problems and adjust goals as work changes. Whether you use them alongside an annual review or in its place, they are more useful when both people know what they want to cover. 

We'll discuss around the here and now—what's working, what's not and what's changed since you last spoke—offering seven discussion points and questions to cover the current situation. You'll also find advice on how to prepare, what to avoid and how to follow up on what you agree. 

Preparing for the conversation 

Both people should have time to prepare. As a manager: 

  • Review the job description and note how the role may have changed 
  • Look at the employee’s goals, achievements and challenges since your last conversation. Bring relevant examples of their work or customer feedback 
  • Check the actions you agreed at previous check-ins or reviews 
  • Share a short agenda in advance and ask what the employee would like to discuss 

Come ready to listen as well as give feedback. The employee may have concerns or ideas that are not visible in their objectives or performance data. 

1. Objectives and SMART goals 

Use each check-in to talk about progress towards the employee’s objectives. When these conversations happen regularly, they can feel more like an opportunity to get support than a judgement on performance. This gives employees space to talk about what is going well and where they are having difficulty. 

If someone has reached a roadblock, explore the options together. Check whether each objective still fits their role and your team’s priorities. If things have changed, agree on a more useful goal rather than asking them to work towards one that no longer makes sense. 

Questions you could ask include: 

  • Which objective are you most pleased with your progress on? 
  • What is getting in the way of the others? 
  • Is there an objective that no longer feels relevant? 
  • What support would help you complete this one on time? 

2. Personal development and career growth 

Ask employees which skills they would like to build and how those skills could help them in their current role or with a future goal. Development does not have to mean a promotion. It might mean taking on a new task, building confidence in an existing strength or learning from a colleague. 

In the CIPD’s Good Work Index 2025, 56% of UK employees said they had opportunities to develop in their role. Among those who reported good opportunities to develop their skills, 14% said they were likely to quit within 12 months, compared with 31% of those who did not. This is an association, so use the conversation to understand what development would be useful to the individual. 

Questions you could ask include: 

  • What skill would make the biggest difference to your work this quarter? 
  • Where would you like to be in two years, and what support would help you get there? 
  • Is there a project or task you would like to try? 

3. Feedback, both ways 

Give feedback while the work is still fresh. A recent, specific example helps the employee understand what went well or what they could do differently. Waiting until a later review can make the details harder to discuss. 

Make room for feedback in both directions. Ask what you could do differently as their manager and whether any team processes make their work harder. Listen to their answer before agreeing on a change. 

Questions you could ask include: 

  • What has gone well since we last spoke, and what helped? 
  • Is there anything I could do differently to support you? 
  • Is there a team process that slows you down? 

When you give feedback, describe something you have seen, explain its effect and agree on a practical next step together. 

4. Issues and concerns 

A check-in gives employees time to raise problems privately and gives managers a chance to explain concerns of their own. Listen first, then agree what needs to happen, who will take each step and when you will review progress. 

Questions you could ask include: 

  • Is anything worrying you at work at the moment? 
  • Is anything outside work affecting you that you would like me to know about? 
  • What would you like us to do next, and when should we check in again? 

When a concern is hard to discuss 

People respond to difficult conversations in different ways. Give them space, while keeping the conversation clear and respectful: 

  • They say everything is fine: explain calmly what you have noticed, give a specific example and ask for their view 
  • They change the subject: acknowledge what they have raised, agree to return to it and then come back to the original concern 
  • They go quiet: allow time to think. If they would rather continue later, agree when you will follow up 

If a concern is serious or cannot be resolved informally, explain which procedure applies and involve HR where appropriate. A formal grievance, a performance concern and mediation may call for different approaches. Follow your organisation’s policy and the current ACAS Code of Practice. 

5. Skills and strengths 

Everyone works best when they're playing to their strengths—and the numbers back that up. Gallup found employees who use their strengths every day are six times more likely to be engaged, and strengths-based development is linked to a 9%–15% increase in engaged employees.  

So, use this to have a conversation with them, Is this person actually using their strengths day to day? If not, could their role, responsibilities, or goals shift to make better use of them? Be specific and be open to changing things on the spot if that's what the discussion calls for. 

Ask: 

  • Which parts of your job do you enjoy most? 
  • When did you last feel you were doing your best work? 
  • Is there a strength you don't get to use enough? 

6. Personal, team and organisational priorities 

Explain what matters most to the team and organisation in the coming weeks, then discuss how the employee’s objectives fit. If priorities have changed, agree which objectives to reorder, add or stop. 

Questions you could ask include: 

  • What do you think the team’s top priority is this month? 
  • Does anything you are working on no longer support that priority? 
  • Do we need to change any of your objectives? 

7. Help and support from the manager 

Make sure the employee knows what support is available, wherever they work. Ask what they need from you before your next check-in. That might be help with a disagreement, planning maternity leave or something else. Agree what you will do and when you will follow up. 

Questions you could ask include: 

  • What do you need from me before we next meet? 
  • Is there anything I agreed to do that I have not done yet? 
  • When would it be useful to check in on this? 

What a performance review should include 

Regular check-ins give both people a record to draw on at a more formal review. ACAS recommends discussing what is going well, where support is needed, and the employee’s development. Give the employee time to share their view, then use this running order: 

  1. Strengths: describe specific work they did well and the difference it made. 
  2. Areas to improve: use evidence and examples, listen to their perspective and agree practical support. 
  3. Career goals: ask what they want to work towards and discuss opportunities that fit the organisation’s plans. 
  4. Next objectives: agree fair, realistic SMART objectives and how you will review progress. 

What to avoid 

Common mistakes, with a better alternative: 

Avoid 

Try instead 

Absolutes: "You're always late with reports." 

"Three of the last four reports were late. What got in the way?" 

Vague praise: "Good job." 

"Your summary for the board was clear and short, and the director used it as is." 

Only negatives 

Start with strengths, then cover one or two areas to improve. 

Doing all the talking 

Ask open questions and let the employee lead part of the conversation. 

References to protected characteristics: "You're doing well for someone your age." 

"Your performance has been excellent, particularly in these areas…" 

Hearsay: "People say you're hard to work with." 

Use examples you have seen yourself, or ask the person directly. 

Keep written review notes factual. Employees can request them through a subject access request, and they may be used as evidence in an employment tribunal. 

Follow-up 

After each conversation: 

  1. Record the actions agreed, who owns them and when they are due. 
  2. Share the review record with the employee and book the next conversation. 
  3. Provide the support or resources you promised. 
  4. Check progress and recognise improvements as they happen. 

Performance & Talent supports regular performance conversations, feedback and objectives, helping managers and employees keep development in view between reviews. 

About the author


Joe Julian

Product Manager - People & Workforce Management

Joe is Product Manager for People & Workforce Management at OneAdvanced, where he manages cloud HR and workforce management products from strategy to adoption. He led the UX overhaul of the Performance & Talent suite, lifting Net Promoter Score by 11 points, and the migration of 180,000 monthly active users to cloud platforms with no downtime. Before moving into software training and product, Joe was a maths and IT teacher.

Share

Contact our sales and support teams. We're here to help.

Contact Us
Speak to our sales team

Speak to our expert consultants for personalised advice and recommendations or to book a demo.

Call us on

0330 343 4000