Managing poor performance at work: A checklist for managing underperformance
This article provides UK managers with step-by-step checklist for dealing with underperformance, from the first conversation to a formal capability process.
by Joe Julian Product Manager - People & Workforce Management

Many teams have periods when someone's work drops below the expected standard. When it happens, you need a fair, consistent way to find out why and help the person improve (as well as a clear process if it doesn't improve).
The below checklist covers how to define the problem, find the cause, give feedback, support improvement, and, if needed, move to a formal capability process in line with the ACAS Code of Practice.
Managing poor performance checklist
1. Define the performance issue
Before you can address poor performance, you must be clear about what the problem is and make it measurable.
Look at the person's work and gather evidence. "Unproductive" is not specific enough: is it missed deadlines, sales below target, or errors in pieces of work? If the issue is about behaviour, use your organisation's competency or behaviour framework to describe it.
When you meet, stick to facts: specific examples, with emails or other records where you have them. Avoid hearsay and make clear the aim is to resolve the problem.
2. Find out what is causing it
Poor performance usually has a cause. Ask the employee what is getting in the way. Is it unclear expectations, too much work, slow processes, or out-of-date systems? Are they facing bullying or discrimination?
Causes can also be outside work, such as caring responsibilities, money worries or bereavement, or the person may not yet have the skills the role needs.
3. Check for health and disability first
Before any formal step, consider whether ill health, a disability, or a condition such as anxiety or depression is affecting performance. Under the Equality Act 2010, employers must consider reasonable adjustments for disabled employees, such as changed hours, different duties, or equipment. Ask the person and refer to occupational health if needed.
4. Give feedback promptly
Many managers put off difficult conversations to protect morale but delay can make performance problems worse. Regular one-to-ones, where both sides discuss progress, achievements, problems, and training, are the foundation of performance management.
Most employees want to know how to improve. Negative feedback can improve performance when it is delivered in the right way. A CIPD report states that negative feedback which is first framed in a positive way is more likely to improve performance than if there is no specific framing or negative framing.
If performance stays low or gets worse, arrange a one-to-one soon after the problem, while the facts are fresh. Explain the purpose of the meeting and keep the tone professional but not judgemental. And be honest. Complicating the message leaves the employee unaware of the problem and unable to fix it.
5. Agree support and actions
Telling someone they have performed badly won't fix the problem on its own. Be ready to offer support. Employees are responsible for doing the job they are paid for, and employers are responsible for giving them the support to do it. The more practical help you offer, the sooner performance is likely to improve.
An informal improvement plan sets out the standard expected, the support the organisation will provide (such as training or a change to processes), and a date to review progress. Keep a written record that both of you agree with.
6. Track progress in one place
Without regular reviews, you can't see whether performance is improving or spot new problems early. In OneAdvanced Performance & Talent, managers and employees hold focused check-ins, set objectives, and give feedback as things happen, so progress and support are recorded in one place.
7. Make use of the person's strengths
Regular check-ins also show what someone does well. Someone who struggles with administration may be strong at building relationships with customers.
There are two ways to use this:
- Use strengths to help with limitations. For example, someone who writes well but finds meetings difficult could prepare written notes before each meeting.
- Change the balance of the role. Reassign some tasks within the team so the person spends more time on work that suits their strengths.
Developing people is often actually cheaper than replacing them.
8. If performance doesn't improve: a formal capability process
If informal support hasn't worked, move to a formal capability process. Follow your organisation's policy and the ACAS Code of Practice on disciplinary and grievance procedures:
- Write to the employee setting out the concerns and inviting them to a formal meeting, with evidence to hand.
- Tell them they have the right to bring a colleague or trade union representative with them.
- Hold the meeting, listen to their response, and consider any new information, including health or personal factors.
- Confirm the outcome in writing. This may be a formal improvement plan with a review period, or a written warning.
- Explain how to appeal and hear any appeal with a different manager where possible.
Poor performance (capability) is different from misconduct, and the two should be handled separately. Dismissal should be a last resort, after the employee has had a fair chance to improve. As outlined by ACAS, the Employment Rights Act 2025 introduces major changes to UK unfair dismissal protections, and takes effect on 1st January 2027. Be sure to take advice from HR or legal before landing on a dismissal decision.
How Performance & Talent helps managers address underperformance
Our Performance & Talent software helps managers spot early signs of underperformance through regular check-ins and feedback, and keeps a record of objectives, conversations, and support.
About the author
Joe Julian
Product Manager - People & Workforce Management
Joe is Product Manager for People & Workforce Management at OneAdvanced, where he manages cloud HR and workforce management products from strategy to adoption. He led the UX overhaul of the Performance & Talent suite, lifting Net Promoter Score by 11 points, and the migration of 180,000 monthly active users to cloud platforms with no downtime. Before moving into software training and product, Joe was a maths and IT teacher.
Contact our sales and support teams. We're here to help.
Speak to our expert consultants for personalised advice and recommendations or to book a demo.
Call us on
0330 343 4000Please enter your details, and our team will contact you shortly.
All fields are required
From simple case logging through to live chat, find the solution you need, faster.
Support centre